Being denied Section 8 because of a past eviction or debt is usually the agency's choice, and your parent can ask for an informal review., If that letter arrived after years on a waiting list, it's natural to read it as final. It may not be final, and she has the right to answer it.

In This Guide

Is This Guide About Your Parent's Situation?

This guide is for a family helping a parent turned down for a Housing Choice Voucher (often called Section 8), or expecting to be, over an old housing-agency debt or a past eviction; if she already has a voucher or subsidized apartment and faces termination or eviction, read whether subsidized housing can evict Mom instead. For how vouchers fit with other rent help, see our affordable senior housing guide.

Denied Section 8 Because of a Past Eviction or Debt: May vs. Must

The most useful thing to know is which kind of ground the agency used. The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) voucher regulation, 24 CFR 982.552, says the agency "may at any time deny program assistance for an applicant" on a list of grounds that includes debts owed to a housing agency and evictions from federally assisted housing in the last five years. A separate set of grounds requires a Section 8 denial, and HUD's guidebook says agency policies "may not be more lenient" than those required rules, so a local plan can't set them aside.,

The ground May or must deny?
A family member was evicted from federally assisted housing in the last 5 years May (agency's choice)
A housing agency has ever terminated voucher assistance for a family member May (agency's choice)
The family currently owes rent or other amounts to any housing agency in connection with Section 8 or public housing May (agency's choice)
The family has not repaid an agency for amounts it paid a landlord for rent, damages or other amounts owed under the lease May (agency's choice)
The family broke an agreement with an agency to pay what it owed May (agency's choice)
A household member was evicted from federally assisted housing for drug-related criminal activity in the last 3 years Must, though the agency may admit the family if it finds the member was successfully rehabilitated or the circumstances no longer exist,
A household member is currently using illegal drugs, or a member's drug use or alcohol abuse may threaten other residents Must, under standards the agency sets
A household member is subject to lifetime registration as a sex offender under a state program Must
A household member was ever convicted of making methamphetamine on the premises of federally assisted housing Must

If Mom Was Denied Section 8 for Owing Money to a Housing Agency

It can be a shock that a balance from an apartment she left long ago followed her here. HUD's voucher guidebook says that before admitting a family to Section 8, the agency must search for each adult in the household in HUD's Enterprise Income Verification (EIV) system's "Debts Owed to PHAs and Terminations" database and, if a debt or termination comes back, decide whether it violates the agency's admissions policies.

A match is where the agency's judgment begins. The voucher regulation, 24 CFR 982.552, says the Section 8 agency, "at its discretion, may offer a family the opportunity to enter an agreement to pay amounts owed," and may set the terms. That's an option to ask about, not a promise. If she does sign one, keep to it: under the same Section 8 rule, breaking an agreement to pay amounts owed is its own ground for denying admission.

If the Denial Is About a Past Eviction

The age and kind of eviction matter, and so does how long ago it happened. The 5-year ground in the federal voucher rule names evictions from federally assisted housing, and it's discretionary, with each agency setting its own policy on it. Under HUD's Section 8 rules, a drug-related eviction from federally assisted housing in the last 3 years requires denial, though the agency may still admit the family if the evicted member successfully completed an approved supervised drug rehabilitation program or the circumstances no longer exist, for example because that person has died or is in prison.,

HUD's voucher guidebook gives an example of that judgment: a family terminated very recently for failing to recertify might be denied Section 8, while a family evicted from public housing 10 or 12 years ago for property destruction might get more consideration, especially if more recent evidence suggests a change in behavior.

What the Agency Can Weigh Before Denying Section 8 for a Past Eviction or Debt

This is where your parent's story counts. For the discretionary grounds, 24 CFR 982.552 says the Section 8 agency "may consider all relevant circumstances such as the seriousness of the case, the extent of participation or culpability of individual family members, mitigating circumstances related to the disability of a family member," and the effect on family members who weren't involved. If the household includes a person with a disability, a Section 8 agency's denial decision is subject to consideration of reasonable accommodation. If a disability played a part in the old debt or eviction, say so plainly and ask for a reasonable accommodation.

If a criminal record is part of the reason, seeing it raised can feel like a verdict, but it isn't one yet, and the agency has a duty to your parent before it decides. A voucher agency must give the applicant and the person the record is about a copy of the record, and a chance to dispute its accuracy and relevance, before it denies admission based on it. Weighing circumstances has a limit, though: HUD's voucher guidebook says the agency must deny Section 8 to lifetime-registered sex offenders and people convicted of methamphetamine production in federally assisted housing without considering circumstances.

Find Your Parent's Local Rules

The same denial can play out differently from one agency to the next, so the local rulebook is where to look next. Each Section 8 agency writes its own policy on these grounds, in a document called its administrative plan. Under 24 CFR 982.54, every voucher agency must adopt a written plan, follow it, and make it available for public review. A voucher agency's administrative plan must cover its standards for denying admission and its informal review procedures for applicants. HUD's guidebook adds that agencies must set local policies on the 5-year eviction and debts-owed grounds. Ask the agency for its plan, and read the sections on denial and on informal reviews before you write anything.

How to Request an Informal Review, Step by Step

Asking for a review isn't picking a fight. It's the process HUD's rules set up for this moment.

1
Step 1

Read the denial notice closely

A Section 8 agency must give a denied applicant prompt written notice with a brief statement of its reasons, and the notice must say the applicant may request an informal review and how to arrange it. Ask the way it says, right away, and keep a copy; the agency's informal review procedures for applicants are in its administrative plan.

2
Step 2

Gather proof of repayment, change and any accommodation request

Bring proof of anything repaid, evidence of what has changed since the eviction or debt, such as proof of repayment or of a repayment agreement you've kept, and a written reasonable accommodation request if a disability was involved.

3
Step 3

Present her objections

A denied voucher applicant must get an opportunity to present written or oral objections, and the reviewer can be anyone the agency designates other than the person who made or approved the decision, or that person's subordinate.

4
Step 4

Get the decision in writing

After the informal review, the voucher agency must notify the applicant of its final decision with a brief statement of the reasons.

A Section 8 informal review isn't required for every decision. The voucher rules list exceptions that include discretionary administrative determinations, general policy issues or class grievances, family unit size under the agency's subsidy standards, and a decision not to approve a tenancy. If the agency says your parent's issue falls in one of those, ask it to name which one in writing.

If She Applied to a HUD Senior Building Instead

If the turn-down came after a long wait for a senior building, the review rights are different from a voucher's, and they depend on the program. Here is how they compare.

Program she applied to What she can ask for Who can't run the review
Section 202 or Section 811 building funded with HUD capital advances A meeting to review the rejection, after the owner promptly tells her in writing why The staff member who made the first decision
HUD multifamily property (HUD's occupancy handbook) A written response or a meeting, within 14 days of the written rejection; the owner must give a final written decision within 5 business days of the response or meeting Anyone involved in the first decision (a staff member not involved must run the meeting)
Public housing An informal hearing, on request, within a reasonable time, so ask the agency in writing how soon The person who made the original decision or that person's subordinate

The steps above are written for a voucher denial. For a senior building, start with the written rejection and answer within its deadline.

Your Next Step This Week

You don't have to untangle all of this at once. This week, ask the agency for its administrative plan and send the review request the way the notice describes., While the review is pending, you can also look into other options, such as a project-based voucher apartment (how it differs from a regular voucher) or a tax credit senior apartment. Our guide to senior priority on housing waiting lists explains how preferences change her place in line.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can an eviction by a private landlord get Mom denied Section 8?

It depends on the agency's plan. The federal 5-year voucher ground names evictions from federally assisted housing, but HUD's guidebook says a Section 8 agency may set additional nondiscriminatory admission criteria, and if it does, it must apply them consistently and list them in its administrative plan., Ask the agency which policy in its plan it applied.

How long does an eviction keep you from Section 8?

It depends on the eviction. A drug-related eviction from federally assisted housing requires a Section 8 denial for 3 years from the date of eviction, with exceptions; for other evictions from federally assisted housing, each agency sets its own policy on the federal 5-year ground, and its administrative plan may list other admission criteria too.,,

Does Mom have to pay a screening fee to apply?

It depends on where she applied. In a HUD multifamily rental property, HUD's occupancy handbook says the owner may not charge application fees or make her pay for screening, including criminal history screening. For a Section 8 voucher, ask the agency in writing what, if anything, it charges.

Learn More

Find personalized help drafting your parent's Section 8 informal review request at brevy.com.


The information on Brevy.com is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional legal, financial, or medical advice. Rules vary by state and program and change frequently. Always verify with the relevant agency or a qualified professional. Brevy is not a law firm, financial advisor, or healthcare provider.

Still have questions?

Brevy answers from this guide and every other guide here, and can check what you qualify for.

BC

Brevy Care Team

Expert eldercare guidance from Brevy's team of healthcare professionals and researchers.