If your NJ Medicaid PCA hours were cut or denied, you can appeal: a NJ FamilyCare plan's decision to reduce the personal care assistant (PCA) hours that keep someone safe at home is not final. The plan's own appeal comes first, a Medicaid Fair Hearing follows if the plan upholds the cut, and a 10-day deadline decides whether the hours keep running while you wait. The letter you are holding has dates on it, so start there.

In This Guide

What to Do in the First Week After a NJ Medicaid PCA Hours Cut

Watching a parent lose hours of help is frightening, especially when you are the one who will fill the gap. The deadlines are short, so the order matters more than the paperwork. You do not have to do it all in one afternoon, but the continuation request in step 3 should not wait.

1
Step 1

Read the notice and write down every date

The plan must send a written notice that says what it decided, why, how to appeal, and how to ask for benefits to continue.

2
Step 2

Ask for the records behind the decision

The notice must tell you that you can get, free of charge and on request, the documents and other information relevant to the decision, including the criteria used.

3
Step 3

Ask for continuation of the hours, in writing if you can

If the hours were authorized before and your parent is already receiving them, this is the deadline to protect first; the section on keeping hours running below has the details.

4
Step 4

File the plan's internal appeal

New Jersey FamilyCare gives 60 calendar days from the date of the plan's denial letter to file the internal appeal, and federal rules let you file it orally or in writing.,

5
Step 5

Decide who will speak for your parent

A provider or an authorized representative can file for a member with the member's written consent.

Why Your NJ Medicaid PCA Hours Were Cut

Hours don't come from the aide or the agency. A State-approved PCA assessment looks at the member's needs: ability to transfer, feed, bathe, toilet, groom and dress, do housekeeping and shopping, and do laundry, along with living environment and cognitive status. For a member of a NJ FamilyCare managed care plan, the plan completes that assessment and authorizes the hours.

New Jersey requires a PCA reassessment at least once every 12 months, or more often if the member's condition warrants. So a lower number after a yearly visit is a decision the plan made from that assessment, and it is the decision you are appealing. That is why step 2 above, asking for the records, matters: compare the written assessment with what your parent can actually do each day, and bring any differences to the appeal.

How the Appeal Works, Step by Step

Route Who decides Deadline How
Internal appeal The health plan 60 calendar days after the plan sends its denial letter Orally or in writing, per the denial letter
Medicaid Fair Hearing The state, with the case heard by the Office of Administrative Law 120 calendar days after the plan's internal-appeal denial letter Request to the state agency (the Division of Medical Assistance and Health Services, DMAHS), per New Jersey's description of where hearing requests are filed

You have to finish the internal appeal first. New Jersey's published description of the process says the member must wait for the result before asking for a Fair Hearing. One exception comes from federal rules: if the plan doesn't follow its own notice and timing requirements, you are treated as having finished the internal appeal and can go straight to a hearing. While you wait, your parent may be going without help, so the timing matters. For a standard appeal, federal Medicaid managed care rules require the state to set a plan decision deadline for a standard appeal of no longer than 30 calendar days from when the plan receives it, which can be extended up to 14 days.

New Jersey also lists a second route: an external appeal through the NJ Department of Banking and Insurance, reviewed by an independent physician. A New Jersey FamilyCare external appeal must be filed in writing within 60 calendar days of the plan's denial letter, on the External Appeal Application the plan encloses, and it can't be filed by phone. The full process, including who hears the case and what happens after the judge decides, is in our guide to New Jersey Medicaid appeals and fair hearings.

Take your actual dates from your own letter. New Jersey's managed care appeal description dates to its 2017 process changes, so confirm the numbers against the notice you received.

Can the Hours Keep Running While You Appeal?

Sometimes, but not automatically. The 10 days run from the letter that cut the hours, so find that letter and check its date first. Federal managed care rules continue benefits during the appeal only if the appeal involves the termination, suspension or reduction of previously authorized services, an authorized provider ordered those services, the original authorization period has not expired, and you ask for continuation on time. New Jersey's version is a 10-calendar-day deadline to ask the plan for continuation, counted from the denial letter or the end of the prior authorization, whichever is later.

There is a second clock, and it is easy to miss. If the plan upholds its decision on your internal appeal, continued benefits end unless you ask for a Fair Hearing and for continuation within 10 calendar days after the plan sends that appeal-denial notice. Taking the full 120 days to file the hearing request can keep the appeal alive but lose the hours in the meantime.

The same rules carry a risk: if the plan's decision is upheld, the plan may be able to recover the cost of the services provided while you waited, consistent with the state's usual recovery policy and the plan's contract. No source we read states New Jersey's specific recovery rule, so ask the plan in writing how recovery would work for your parent. It is a hard bind, hours now against a possible bill later, but the risk is a reason to ask questions, not to skip the request, since the alternative is going without the help in the meantime. If the 10 days have already passed, you can still file the internal appeal on its separate 60-day clock, and you can ask the plan whether any continuation is still available.

If the cut has already taken effect, federal Medicaid hearing rules add two ways to ask for hours back:

  • A state may reinstate services if a hearing is requested no more than 10 days after the date of action.
  • A state must reinstate them if all three are true: the action came without required advance notice, the request comes within 10 days of receiving the notice, and the agency finds the action did not result from the application of law or policy.

A notice with less than 10 days' warning is not automatically defective, since some exceptions allow it., Ask the plan or a representative which of these applies to your parent's notice.

If your parent is in a plan that is an integrated dual-eligible plan, check the plan's materials, because the federal 60-day appeal filing rule for managed care plans does not govern those plans' internal appeals.

Would Switching From Agency Care to PPP Help?

Sometimes families hope that moving from agency aides to the Personal Preference Program will fix a cut. It won't by itself, and it helps to know why. The plan's PCA assessment sets the authorized hours either way, and a PPP member receives a monthly budget based on those hours, using the hours from the initial assessment or the most recent reassessment. No source we read says the hours carry over unchanged when someone moves from an agency to PPP, so don't count on that.

Agency PCA Personal Preference Program
Who delivers the hours An accredited home care agency A worker the member hires, managed with a monthly budget
Who sets the authorized hours The plan's PCA assessment The same assessment sets the budget
Relative or friend as worker Not for a spouse Allowed

What PPP does change is who runs the care. DMAHS describes agency PCA as hours delivered by an accredited home care agency, while PPP members get a budget, and the state says they are not restricted to buying the same number of hours they were authorized. A PPP member can hire a relative or friend as the worker, which an agency can't do for a spouse. Our guide to the New Jersey Personal Preference Program covers who can be paid, the budget and the fiscal intermediary for each plan.

The route in is the same one for everyone: contact the health plan and ask for a PCA assessment for enrollment into PPP. The plan completes the assessment and application and sends the file to the fiscal intermediary. To join the Personal Preference Program (PPP), the member must be approved for PCA and need it for at least six months, and be able to direct the care or have an authorized representative who can.

If you are the one who would be hired, the worker requirements, background checks and 40-hour weekly limit are covered in our Personal Preference Program guide.

If you are in the middle of a fight over hours, ask the plan how a PPP assessment would interact with your pending appeal before you switch, and keep the appeal going in the meantime.

If Your Parent Isn't on NJ FamilyCare Yet

PCA hours are a NJ FamilyCare benefit, so there is nothing to appeal until your parent is enrolled. Our guides to how to apply for New Jersey Medicaid and to New Jersey MLTSS walk through the application and the long-term care program.

Who to Call About a PCA Hours Cut

  • Your parent's health plan: member services, on the card. This is the first call for the records, the appeal and a PCA assessment for PPP.
  • PPP State Program Office: the Division of Medical Assistance and Health Services, P.O. Box 712, Attention: Personal Preference Program, Trenton, NJ 08625, telephone 609-631-2481.
  • PPP payroll: DMAHS lists two fiscal intermediaries, Palco for Horizon NJ Health participants and Public Partnership LLC (PPL) for the other plans; plans can move to new vendors, so confirm yours with the plan.,

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a relative or friend help me at the hearing?

Yes. At a Medicaid Fair Hearing you can represent yourself or use legal counsel, a relative, a friend or another spokesperson, and the state must tell you that in writing.

Learn More

Find personalized help with a New Jersey home care hours decision at brevy.com.


The information on Brevy.com is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional legal, financial, or medical advice. Rules vary by state and program and change frequently. Always verify with the relevant agency or a qualified professional. Brevy is not a law firm, financial advisor, or healthcare provider.

Still have questions?

Brevy answers from this guide and every other guide here, and can check what you qualify for.

BC

Brevy Care Team

Expert eldercare guidance from Brevy's team of healthcare professionals and researchers.