Colorado Medigap premiums have no single price: age-65 Plan G is listed from $128 to $393 a month in ZIP code 80202, by Brevy's reading of the Division of Insurance's spring 2026 non-smoker survey. If you are comparing quotes or facing an increase, the same plan letter differs because company, age, ZIP code and tobacco use all move the price. Colorado also lets some insurers offer a choice between attained-age and issue-age pricing.,,

In This Guide

Why Does the Same Colorado Medigap Plan Cost Different Amounts?

The Colorado Division of Insurance and Colorado SHIP, in their September 2026 Medigap guide, say Medigap premiums may vary according to your age, where you live and whether you use tobacco. The guide adds that cost is usually the only difference between Medigap policies with the same plan letter, and it tells readers to ask a company about the rates where they live. CMS likewise says that where you live, medical underwriting and discounts can affect the amount of a Medigap premium, and that the cost of Medigap policies can vary widely depending on the insurance company, the plan and where you live.

The Division's guide notes that the same plan can show many different monthly premiums across companies, as in the $128 to $393 a month spread for age-65 Plan G in ZIP code 80202 shown below. It says some higher premiums reflect added benefits such as a 24-hour nurse hotline, while in other cases the benefits are the same. Its chart key also notes that a household or marital discount may be available, to be checked with each company.

How Do Attained-Age, Issue-Age and Community Rating Work?

Medigap policies are priced under one of three rating methods, according to CMS's Medigap guide.

Rating method How the premium is set Colorado chart label
Attained-age Based on your current age, so it goes up as you get older; often the least expensive at first, but can eventually become the most expensive AA
Issue-age Based on the age you are when you buy the policy; may rise with inflation and other factors but not because you enter an older age bracket IA
Community-rated Generally the same premium for everyone, regardless of age or gender; may rise with inflation and other factors but not because of your age CR

The Division's September 2026 guide labels each policy in its premium charts AA (premiums are based on your current age), IA (premiums are based on your age when you buy the policy) or CR (premiums are basically the same for everyone in your area). Rating method is not the only thing that sets the price, since CMS names where you live, medical underwriting and discounts as other factors.,

Can You Choose a Rating Method in Colorado?

Sometimes. Under Colorado Division of Insurance Regulation 4-3-1 (3 CCR 702-4), Section 14.D, issuers have the option of offering Medigap plans on an attained-age basis, an issue-age basis or a dual rating basis, and they must give consumers adequate information to make an informed choice. An issuer is not required to offer both.

When an issuer does offer dual rating, the regulation says an individual policyholder should have a choice whether to elect an issue-age or attained-age rating methodology, and both options shall be presented before purchase. The attained-age and issue-age rates shall be demonstrated to be actuarially equivalent.

The switching rule runs one way. Policyholders should be allowed to switch from attained-age to issue-age rating, but shall not be allowed to switch from issue-age to attained-age. If you hold an attained-age policy and the age-based increases are becoming a burden, ask the company in writing whether it allows a switch to issue-age rating.

Who Approves Colorado Medigap Rates?

The Commissioner of Insurance does. Section 14.C of Colorado's Regulation 4-3-1 says an issuer shall not use or change premium rates for a Medigap policy unless the rates, rating schedule and supporting documentation have been filed with and approved by the Commissioner. Section 13.C requires each Medigap issuer to file its rates for approval annually. The Colorado Division of Insurance describes plan and premium filings as requests from companies that the Division reviews, and its list of filing types includes Medicare Supplement.

Approval comes with a loss-ratio standard. Three parts of the regulation matter to a policyholder:

  • The benchmark. Under Section 13.A.1.a, an individual indemnity-form Medigap policy can be expected, over the entire period for which rates are computed, to return to policyholders in aggregate benefits at least 65 percent of the aggregate premiums earned (75 percent for group policies).
  • Refunds. Section 13.B.4 provides for a refund or credit only when the benchmark loss ratio exceeds the adjusted experience loss ratio and the amount exceeds a de minimis level, which the cited text does not put a dollar figure on.
  • Rate-increase hearings. Under Section 13.D, the Commissioner of Insurance may hold a public hearing on a Medigap rate-increase request if the form's experience for the previous reporting period does not comply with the applicable loss-ratio standard.

The Division's guide says Medigap premiums can change throughout the year, that consumers should verify current rates with the company marketing the plan, and that a Medigap policy is guaranteed renewable from year to year as long as the premium is paid.

How Much Do Colorado Medigap Premiums Vary by Company?

The Division of Insurance's September 2026 guide reflects its spring 2026 survey of Colorado companies. The charts cover non-smokers aged 65, 70, 75 and 80, plus disabled beneficiaries under 65, for ZIP code 80202 only, and the Division warns that rates are accurate at the date of printing but may change at any time. Its companion 2026-2027 premium chart workbook lists separate female and male monthly rates for each company.

Scanning every company row in the age-65 non-smoker tables for ZIP code 80202, Brevy's reading of the workbook (not a figure the Division states) finds a wide spread for the same plan letter:

Plan Lowest rate listed Highest rate listed
Plan G $128 a month (female, Atlantic Capital Life Assurance Insurance, attained-age) $393 a month (male, Guarantee Trust Life Insurance Company, attained-age)
Plan N $93 a month (same Atlantic Capital female row) $315 a month (same Guarantee Trust male row)

These are survey examples for one ZIP code, not a statewide average and not a quote. They also show why the rating method matters. In the Division's spring 2026 survey for ZIP code 80202, one attained-age-rated company, Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield, lists a female Plan G rate that rises from $183 at age 65 to $295 at age 75 and $364 at age 80. The companies are named only because the Division's workbook names them.

What Do Plans G and N Pay?

Compare the same plan letter, since Medigap policies are standardized: every policy with the same letter offers the same basic benefits regardless of the insurer. In most states they are sold as lettered plans A through D, F, G and K through N. Massachusetts, Minnesota and Wisconsin standardize their plans differently.

Plan G Plan N
Benefits Same as Plan F except that it does not cover the annual Part B deductible Pays 100% of the Part B coinsurance except for a copayment of up to $20 for some office visits and up to $50 for emergency-room visits that don't result in an inpatient admission
Part B excess charge Covered, per CMS's chart Not covered, per CMS's chart

Plans C and F cannot be sold to people who became newly eligible for Medicare on or after January 1, 2020.

For the head-to-head, see Medigap Plan G vs. Plan N. Medigap covers only one person, so a couple needs two separate policies and gets two separate quotes.

Are Colorado Medigap Premiums Higher Under 65?

Colorado requires Medigap insurers to market to disabled Medicare beneficiaries under age 65, and the Division's guide says their rates may be higher than at age 65. At 65, Colorado beneficiaries who bought Medigap while disabled and under 65 again have Medigap guaranteed issue rights and should review available policies to see whether they can get a better price on another policy.

Section 10.E of Colorado's Regulation 4-3-1 limits how much higher. An issuer must demonstrate compliance for each plan, type and form level in one of three ways:

  • by charging persons under 65 a premium rate that does not exceed the highest available premium rate for that plan, type and form level;
  • by making a premium adjustment for persons under 65 equal to the premium adjustment for persons over 65; or
  • in the case of a filing that introduces a new Medigap product to Colorado under Section 10.E of Colorado's Regulation 4-3-1, by charging persons under 65 a rate equal to 1.5 times the age-65 premium rate.

The 1.5 times figure applies only to the new-product special case, not to every under-65 Medigap rate. The windows that give people under 65 the right to buy are covered in Medigap in Colorado: Open Enrollment, Under 65 and Guaranteed Issue.

How Do You Compare Colorado Medigap Quotes?

Compare the same plan letter first, then the things that change the price over time. The Division's guide suggests asking each company:

  1. How frequently does the premium increase because of age?
  2. Has the premium for this policy increased in the last three years for other reasons, and by how much?
  3. Does the company offer discounts or additional benefits?

Then ask which rating method each quote uses, and whether the company offers the other. Quotes at your own address matter, because the Division's survey examples cover ZIP code 80202 only.,

To find quotes for your own ZIP code, the Division's guide says you can enter your zip code at Medicare.gov and find all the Medigap policies available where you live; 1-800-Medicare is the number it gives for Medicare publications. Ask for the same plan letter from each company, and ask whether a household discount applies.

Whether you can shop freely depends on timing. Under Section 10.A of Regulation 4-3-1, no issuer may deny or condition a Medigap policy, or discriminate in its pricing because of health status, when your application is submitted before or during the six-month period that begins with the first day of the first month you are both 65 or older and enrolled in Medicare Part B. Outside that window, the Division's guide says there is generally no guarantee you can buy a new Medigap policy, because insurers decide whether to insure you based on your health, so a cheaper quote can still be declined. One exception: Colorado beneficiaries who bought Medigap while disabled and under 65 get guaranteed issue rights again at 65. Colorado's open enrollment and guaranteed-issue rules are laid out in Medigap in Colorado: Open Enrollment, Under 65 and Guaranteed Issue.

If you are replacing a policy, the order matters: collect quotes, apply, and cancel the old policy last. Protect your coverage first. The Division's guide warns that in most cases there is no guarantee you can buy a new Medigap policy when switching, that insurers decide whether to insure you based on health, and that you should not cancel a current policy until you are accepted for a new one. Under Section 22 of Regulation 4-3-1, a replacing issuer must waive preexisting-condition and waiting periods to the extent they had elapsed under the original policy, and Colorado Medigap policies must carry a notice that you may return the policy within 30 days of its delivery for a refund of the premium.

Who Can Help You Compare Colorado Medigap Prices?

Colorado SHIP gives free, detailed and personal help with Medigap and other Medicare questions at 1-888-696-7213, and its counselors do not sell or promote any health insurance. For a problem with a current Medigap policy, the Colorado Division of Insurance's guide says to file a complaint with the Division at 303-894-7490 or insurance@dora.state.co.us, and states that complaints must be in writing.

The Division's Medicare Supplement Insurance Policies in Colorado guide (September 2026) holds the premium charts. For the national picture, see Medigap Pricing.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Colorado regulate Medigap rates?

Yes. The Commissioner of Insurance must approve Medigap rates before an issuer uses them, as the rate-approval section above explains.

Why did my Colorado Medigap premium go up?

An attained-age policy is priced on your current age, so it rises as you get older, according to CMS. CMS also says premiums may go up because of inflation and other factors, and the Division's guide says premiums can change throughout the year. Ask the company which reason applies, and whether a switch to issue-age rating is available.,

Learn More

Find personalized help comparing Colorado Medigap policies with Brevy's care navigator at brevy.com.


The information on Brevy.com is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional legal, financial, or medical advice. Rules vary by state and program and change frequently. Always verify with the relevant agency or a qualified professional. Brevy is not a law firm, financial advisor, or healthcare provider.

Still have questions?

Brevy answers from this guide and every other guide here, and can check what you qualify for.

BC

Brevy Care Team

Expert eldercare guidance from Brevy's team of healthcare professionals and researchers.