When your Medicare drug plan won't cover a prescription, you can file a Part D coverage determination, and the plan then has 72 hours to answer. That is a formal request on a federal clock, and it's 24 hours if waiting would put your health at risk. You don't have to accept the no at the pharmacy counter. Here's who can file, how to do it, and what happens if the plan misses its deadline.

In This Guide

What Is a Medicare Part D Coverage Determination, and What Can It Get You?

A coverage determination is the first formal decision your drug plan makes about whether, and how, it will cover a specific drug for you. It's the official way to say "I think you got this wrong, please decide." According to CMS, the term reaches further than most people expect. It includes the plan's decision on whether to pay for a drug you believe may be covered, the amount you're charged, and any limit or requirement you disagree with.

The plainest ask is a request for a drug that has strings attached: your plan covers it, but only after prior authorization, or only up to a quantity limit, or only after you've tried a cheaper drug first (step therapy). CMS counts a decision on whether you've met a prior authorization or similar requirement as a coverage determination too, so you're asking the plan to approve the drug, or lift the restriction, for you.

Then there are two kinds of exception requests, and they're the ones people reach for most when a drug gets denied:

  • A formulary exception asks the plan to cover a drug that isn't on its formulary, the list of drugs it normally pays for. It can also reach a restriction: the regulation lists an exception to a coverage policy that keeps a drug from being covered because of step therapy, dosage limits, or therapeutic substitution.
  • A tiering exception asks the plan to charge you a lower, cheaper cost-sharing tier for a drug it does cover.

Both exception types lean on one thing: your prescriber's medical reasoning for why you need this specific drug. For a formulary exception, the plan must grant it whenever it determines the drug is medically necessary, consistent with your prescriber's statement, and that it would be covered but for being off the formulary. That statement is also what sets the plan's decision clock ticking.

How to Ask for a Medicare Part D Coverage Determination

You don't have to do this alone. You can request a coverage determination yourself, your appointed representative can do it for you, or your prescribing doctor (or other prescriber) can file on your behalf. For an exception, having your prescriber drive it usually helps, because the plan needs their supporting statement anyway. Here are the steps, in order.

  1. Decide what you're asking for. Are you asking the plan to cover a drug, to lift a restriction like step therapy, to charge a lower tier, or to pay you back for a drug you already bought? Each is a coverage determination, and the last one is a payment request.
  2. Ask your prescriber for a supporting statement if you need an exception. For a tiering exception, it must say that the preferred drugs for your condition would not be as effective for you as the one you're requesting, would have adverse effects for you, or both. For a formulary exception, it must say the requested drug is medically necessary because the covered alternatives on the formulary would be less effective or harmful, or because a formulary or step-therapy drug has been ineffective or is likely to cause an adverse reaction. The statement can be oral, but the plan may then require it in writing, along with additional medical documentation. A statement doesn't guarantee approval, so the more specific your prescriber is about your situation, the better.
  3. Send the request to your plan. A request for a drug can be made orally or in writing; a payment request has to be in writing unless your plan accepts oral ones. The request goes to your plan or to the entity the plan directs you to. If you write it, CMS says you can use its Model Coverage Determination Request Form, a form your plan provides, or any written document that you, your prescriber, or someone else prepares.
  4. Say if it's urgent. If waiting could seriously harm your health, you or your prescriber can ask for the expedited, 24-hour track (more on that below).
  5. Watch the clock. A standard request gets a decision in 72 hours and an expedited one in 24, and for an exception the clock runs from the moment your prescriber's statement arrives. If you hear nothing by the deadline, see the section below.

Here is how that can play out. Say your plan requires you to try a cheaper drug first, and your doctor says it hasn't worked for you. On a Monday at 9 a.m. your prescriber sends the request and the supporting statement together. A standard decision is due no later than Thursday at 9 a.m., or Tuesday at 9 a.m. if your prescriber asks for the fast track and the plan accepts that it qualifies. If the statement instead arrives Friday, the clock starts Friday, not Monday. Those dates are illustrations. Your plan's notice states the actual decision.

What Deadlines the Plan Must Meet

Here's where it pays to know the rules, because your plan is on a federally set clock. The timeframes come straight from the Code of Federal Regulations (42 CFR 423.568 and 42 CFR 423.572), and CMS spells them out on its coverage-determinations page.

For a straightforward request for a drug (not an exception), the plan must give you notice of its decision no later than 72 hours after it receives a standard request, or 24 hours for an expedited one. Exception requests run on the same 72-hour and 24-hour deadlines, with one big difference: the clock doesn't start when you file. It starts when the plan receives your prescriber's supporting statement.

Type of request Deadline to decide When the clock starts
Standard request for a drug 72 hours When the plan receives the request
Expedited (fast) request 24 hours When the plan receives the request
Exception (formulary or tiering) 72 hours standard, or 24 hours expedited When the plan receives your prescriber's supporting statement (or 14 days after the request if none arrives)
Standard payment (reimbursement) 14 calendar days When the plan receives the request

So if your prescriber is slow with the statement, the plan can't sit on your request forever: once 14 calendar days pass, the 72-hour (or 24-hour) clock starts anyway. If you already paid for the drug and want the money back, put that request in writing, and the plan has 14 calendar days to answer.

Those hour limits are ceilings, not the time the plan is entitled to take. Federal rules say the plan must decide as quickly as your health condition requires, and no later than the deadline, so if your need is urgent you can press for an answer sooner. The plan can tell you its decision verbally first, but it must follow up in writing within 3 calendar days.

If the plan misses its deadline, you aren't stuck waiting. Missing the deadline counts as a denial (an adverse coverage determination), and the plan must send your request to an outside reviewer, the Independent Review Entity (IRE), within 24 hours of the deadline passing. If you've heard nothing by the deadline, call the plan and ask it to confirm the IRE referral.

When You Can Ask for a Fast Decision

Waiting days to learn whether you can get a medication you need is frightening, and asking for the fast track is a legitimate use of the rules, not a favor. The 24-hour expedited track isn't automatic, though. You (or your prescriber) can ask for it when waiting for a standard decision could seriously jeopardize your life, your health, or your ability to regain maximum function.

Here's how it plays out in practice. If your prescriber tells the plan that a standard wait would put your health at that kind of risk, the plan must grant the fast track. According to Medicare, a plan can also decide on its own that your request qualifies. So when speed matters, loop your prescriber in early. You or your prescriber can make an expedited request by phone or in writing.

What If the Answer Is Still No

A coverage determination is only round one. If the plan denies your request, you have the right to appeal, and the appeal is a separate process with its own deadlines, called a redetermination. That's the next step, not the end of the road.

The redetermination clock is separate from the plan's decision clock. For a standard redetermination, you (or your prescriber, acting for you) must ask the plan that made the decision, in writing, within 60 calendar days after you receive the written notice. The notice is presumed to reach you 5 calendar days after its date, and the plan may extend the deadline if you show good cause. Don't let the notice sit in a pile of mail.

We walk through all five appeal levels, the deadlines, and the fast track for urgent cases in our guide on how to appeal a Medicare denial.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does a Part D coverage determination take?

For a standard request, your plan must decide within 72 hours. For an expedited (fast) request, it's 24 hours. For an exception request, those same clocks don't start until the plan receives your prescriber's supporting statement, or 14 calendar days after the request if no statement arrives.

What's the difference between a formulary exception and a tiering exception?

A formulary exception asks the plan to cover a drug that isn't on its drug list at all, or to lift a restriction like step therapy. A tiering exception asks the plan to charge you a lower, cheaper cost-sharing tier for a drug it already covers. Both need your prescriber's supporting statement explaining the medical reason.

Can my doctor request the coverage determination for me?

Yes. You, your appointed representative, or your prescribing doctor can file the request. For an exception, your prescriber's involvement is especially useful, since the plan needs their supporting statement before its decision clock even starts.

Can I ask by phone, or does it have to be in writing?

A request for a drug can be made orally or in writing. A payment request has to be in writing unless your plan accepts oral ones. If you write, you can use the CMS model form, your plan's form, or your own document.

The plan already made me pay full price. Can I get that money back?

You can file a standard payment request asking the plan to reimburse you for a covered drug you paid for out of pocket. The plan has 14 calendar days to decide that request.

What happens if the plan says no?

You can appeal. The appeal, called a redetermination, is a separate process with its own timeline: for a standard one, you have 60 calendar days from receiving the written notice to ask the plan, in writing.

Learn More

Find personalized help asking your Medicare drug plan to cover a denied prescription at brevy.com.


The information on Brevy.com is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional legal, financial, or medical advice. Rules vary by state and program and change frequently. Always verify with the relevant agency or a qualified professional. Brevy is not a law firm, financial advisor, or healthcare provider.

Still have questions?

Brevy answers from this guide and every other guide here, and can check what you qualify for.

BC

Brevy Care Team

Expert eldercare guidance from Brevy's team of healthcare professionals and researchers.