SHIP vs. broker comes down to who pays: a SHIP counselor is paid by the federal government to give unbiased help and has nothing to sell, while a Medicare broker is paid a federally capped commission by the insurance company whose plan you enroll in. Both help you for free, and both can be useful. Knowing which is which is how you use each one well.

In This Guide

What Each One Is

A SHIP, the State Health Insurance Assistance Program, gives free, personalized, and unbiased Medicare counseling to people with Medicare, their families, and their caregivers. It is a public program, not a business, and it has no plan to sell. Its counselors help with your plan choices and with getting coverage through Original Medicare, Medicare Advantage, Part D, and Medigap, and, if money is tight, help you apply for Medicaid, the Medicare Savings Programs, and Extra Help.

A Medicare broker, or independent agent, is a licensed insurance professional who can sell you a Medicare Advantage or Part D plan, and often Medigap. A broker's job is to place a policy: they earn a living only when you enroll, and only in the plans they are appointed to represent.

Neither one bills you. The difference is upstream, in where their money comes from.

Who Pays a SHIP Counselor? The Federal Government

SHIP is funded by the federal government. The Administration for Community Living (ACL), an operating division of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, funds the state SHIP programs through grants, so there is no bill to send you.

Because the money comes from a grant rather than from selling anything, the counselor has no financial stake in which plan you pick. Federal law reinforces that: a state applying for SHIP grant money must assure that its staff, volunteers included, have no conflict of interest in providing the counseling. ACL's conflict-of-interest guidance applies that rule directly: no one may be a licensed insurance agent and a SHIP team member at the same time, which ACL treats as a violation of the SHIP statute, on the reasoning that the program cannot ensure an active agent would counsel in an unbiased way. Medicare's own handbook puts the boundary plainly: SHIPs are not connected to any insurance company or health plan.

Who Pays a Medicare Broker? The Insurer, at a Federally Capped Rate

A broker is paid a commission by the insurance company whose plan you enroll in. The amount is not set by the insurer at all. It is set and capped by federal regulation.

Under 42 CFR 422.2274 for Medicare Advantage and the parallel 42 CFR 423.2274 for Part D, CMS sets a national "fair market value" (FMV), the amount it determines could reasonably be expected to be paid for an enrollment or continued enrollment, and beginning with contract year 2025 plans are limited to the compensation amounts in that section. Through 2024, an MA plan could pay at or below FMV for an initial enrollment and up to 50 percent of FMV at renewal. The regulation's base figures for Medicare Advantage run from January 1, 2021: $539 nationally, $607 in Connecticut, Pennsylvania, and Washington, D.C., $672 in California and New Jersey, and $370, lower rather than higher, in Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands. For a Part D drug plan the national base is $81.

Those are the regulation's base amounts, not this year's cap: a one-time $100 increase applied for 2025, and each year after, the figure is recomputed by adding a growth percentage published in CMS's annual rate announcement, so the current-year amount is materially higher and that announcement is where to find it. Since 2025, a plan that pays renewal-year compensation pays it at 50 percent of FMV, a fixed rate rather than a ceiling.

Two things follow from that. First, the agent's pay for your enrollment is that capped commission, and it comes from the insurer, not from you. Second, an agent sells for the insurers that have appointed them, under state licensing and appointment rules, so they can offer you only those insurers' plans. A broker who carries three carriers is choosing among three, not among all the plans in your county.

The Incentive Difference That Actually Matters

Once you know who pays, the honest question is whether the payment bends the advice. Federal rule anticipates exactly that concern for brokers. Beginning with contract year 2025, no provision of a plan's contract with an agent or broker may have the direct or indirect effect of creating, in the regulation's words, "an incentive that would reasonably be expected to inhibit an agent or broker's ability to objectively assess and recommend which plan best fits the health care needs of a beneficiary." The rule is there because the risk is real: a commission paid only on enrollment, only in appointed plans, can shape advice, even when it is capped and regulated.

Three details in the same regulation shape a switch specifically, and they are worth knowing before one is suggested to you:

  • Switching Medicare Advantage plans. A move from one Medicare Advantage plan to another counts as a renewal year, so the agent is paid, if at all, at the renewal rate of half of fair market value. A move across product lines, between an MA or MA-PD plan and a stand-alone drug plan or a Cost Plan, is paid at the higher initial-enrollment rate, pro-rated for the months you are actually enrolled.
  • MA-only plus a drug plan. If you take an MA-only plan plus a separate drug plan, each plan may pay for its own enrollment, where an MA-PD pays the MA compensation only.
  • Switching early. If you change plans within the first three months of enrolling, the regulation generally requires the entire commission to be taken back, which gives an agent a direct reason to discourage an early switch. There are listed exceptions, such as enrolling effective October 1, November 1 or December 1 and then switching in the Annual Election Period for January 1.

None of that makes an agent's advice wrong. It is the structure sitting behind it, and the same rule gives you something to ask for: before you enroll, the regulation requires that CMS's required questions and topics about your needs be fully discussed, including whether your current doctors and pharmacy are in the plan's network and whether your prescriptions are covered. You are entitled to that conversation, and you can ask for it by name.

SHIP sits on the other side of that line by design. It has no commission to earn and no plan to sell, and the law keeps active agents out of the counselor role. That is the whole value of a SHIP conversation: the person across the table gains nothing from your decision either way.

A licensed agent does something SHIP cannot: actually place the policy. That makes the two complementary. Get the neutral read first, then enroll with whoever you like.

SHIP vs. Broker at a Glance

SHIP counselor Medicare broker / agent
Who pays them The federal government, through ACL grants The insurer whose plan you enroll in, a federally capped commission
Cost to you Free Free
Has a plan to sell No Yes, the plans they are appointed to represent
Can enroll you in a policy Helps you enroll; does not sell it for a commission Yes, that is the job
Federal guardrail Must have no conflict of interest; no active insurance license allowed Commission limited to FMV amounts; contract terms may not create an incentive that undercuts objective advice
Best used for A neutral read on your plan choices and finding help paying health care costs Placing the specific plan you have decided on

When to Use SHIP vs. a Broker

Call SHIP first when you want your options laid out by someone with no stake in the outcome: when you are deciding between Medicare Advantage and Original Medicare with a Medigap plan, when money is tight and you want help applying for the Medicare Savings Programs and Extra Help alongside the plans, or when you simply do not want the conversation to be a sales conversation. Choosing a plan is stressful, and being pitched makes it harder; you are allowed to slow down and get a neutral read before you sign anything. You can find your SHIP through the locator at shiphelp.org or by calling 1-877-839-2675.

Call a broker when you know what you want and need a licensed agent to place the policy, or when you want someone who will handle the paperwork and stay with you at renewal. Ask which carriers they represent, so you know how wide their view is. There is nothing wrong with using both: get the neutral read from SHIP, then call an agent to enroll.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a Medicare broker really free?

You don't pay the agent. The agent is paid a commission by the insurance company whose plan you enroll in, and that commission is capped by federal rule.

Does using a broker make my plan cost more?

Not through any charge from the agent. The commission is paid by the insurer whose plan you choose and is limited to amounts set by federal rule, so it never arrives as a bill to you. What you pay is the plan's own premium and cost-sharing, so compare those across plans, with SHIP's help if you want a neutral read.

If a broker is regulated, why use SHIP at all?

Because a broker can only sell the plans they represent, and earns only when you enroll. SHIP has no plan to sell and no commission to earn, and federal law keeps active insurance agents out of the counselor role, so a SHIP counselor can look across every option without a stake in which one you pick.,

Can a SHIP counselor sign me up for a plan?

SHIP counseling covers enrollment help, not selling. A counselor can walk you through the process and help you enroll, but they do not place the policy for a commission the way an agent does.

Learn More

Find free, unbiased help comparing your Medicare options at brevy.com.


The information on Brevy.com is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional legal, financial, or medical advice. Rules vary by state and program and change frequently. Always verify with the relevant agency or a qualified professional. Brevy is not a law firm, financial advisor, or healthcare provider.

Still have questions?

Brevy answers from this guide and every other guide here, and can check what you qualify for.

BC

Brevy Care Team

Expert eldercare guidance from Brevy's team of healthcare professionals and researchers.