If your mom or dad needs more help than you can give, assisted living vs. home care comes down to hours: home care is priced by the hour, while assisted living is priced by the month and includes housing, meals and 24-hour supervision. At the 2025 national medians from the CareScout Cost of Care Survey, in-home care at 44 hours a week ($80,080 a year) already costs more than a year of assisted living ($74,400). Here's what each one gives your parent, what Medicare and Medicaid will and won't pay, and how to tell which one fits.,

In This Guide

Assisted Living vs. Home Care: How Do They Compare?

Both options exist for the same reason: your parent needs help with daily life but doesn't need a nursing home. The difference is where the help happens and how it's paid for. Here's the side-by-side, built from federal descriptions of each setting and the CareScout 2025 national medians.,,

Assisted living Home care
Where your parent lives Own apartment or room in a residential community, with shared common areas Their own home
Who gives the care Community staff, with 24-hour supervision and on-site staff Family and friends, plus paid aides, nurses or therapists who come to the home
How much help Available around the clock As many hours as you arrange and pay for
Medical care Some health care, less intensive than a nursing home Paid nurses and therapists can come in; home care aides handle daily tasks
Meals, housekeeping, activities Up to three meals a day, housekeeping, laundry, social and recreational activities Not part of the rate; your parent or the family covers groceries and the home's upkeep
Who picks the caregiver Varies by facility; your parent may not get to choose You and your parent
National median cost (CareScout 2025) $6,200 a month, $74,400 a year $35 an hour; $80,080 a year at 44 hours a week
Medicare Doesn't pay for custodial care or a long-term stay Doesn't pay custodial care alone; covers part-time skilled care at home
Medicaid Depends on your state's programs Home health is mandatory; other in-home help depends on your state

What Assisted Living Gives Your Parent

The National Institute on Aging (NIA) describes assisted living as a residential setting for people who need help with daily care, but not as much help as a nursing home provides. Residents usually live in their own apartments or rooms and share common areas.

Your parent would typically get up to three meals a day, help with personal care and medications, housekeeping and laundry, and 24-hour supervision, security and on-site staff, plus social and recreational activities, per NIA. Some health care may be on offer too, but not as much as in a nursing home. The Administration for Community Living (ACL) goes further and calls assisted living a group living setting that generally does not provide medical care.

Two things trip families up. First, assisted living communities typically offer a few levels of care, and residents pay more if they need extra services. How much more is set community by community, so ask for the written fee schedule and the license information before you tour. Second, the rules change at the state line. The HHS Office of the Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation (ASPE) says residential care settings are licensed and regulated at the state level, and that state requirements vary considerably.,

So what "assisted living" means, and what it must provide, depends on where your parent lives. Our assisted living by state guide covers each state's version.

What Home Care Gives Your Parent

Most long-term care happens at home, according to ACL's LongTermCare.gov. NIA says that in many cases the people providing it are family members, friends and neighbors, and that most of it is personal care: help with bathing, dressing, eating and taking medications, plus supervision to make sure a person is safe.

Paid help layers on top. A nurse, a home health or home care aide, or a therapist can come to the home, and per NIA, paid caregivers can help your parent with medications, wound care, medical equipment and physical therapy. ACL notes that home care agencies provide services daily or as needed.

One thing to keep straight: "home care" (help with daily tasks) and "home health" (skilled nursing and therapy a doctor orders) aren't the same service, and Medicare treats them very differently. Our home care vs. home health guide lays out the difference, and personal care services explains exactly what a home care aide does.

Assisted Living vs. Home Care Cost: Which Costs More?

Here are the numbers from one survey, so you're comparing like with like. The CareScout 2025 Cost of Care Survey, released in March 2026, puts the U.S. national medians at:

Type of care National median Per year
Assisted living community $6,200 a month $74,400
In-home non-medical caregiver $35 an hour $80,080 at 44 hours a week
Skilled nursing in the home $90 an hour Hourly rate only

So is home care cheaper than assisted living? For part-time help it can be, because home care is priced by the hour and you pay only for the hours you use. But at the CareScout 2025 national medians, a year of in-home care at 44 hours a week ($80,080) already costs more than a year of assisted living ($74,400). Divide $74,400 by $35 an hour and 52 weeks, and the break-even lands at about 41 hours a week; below that, home care costs less on these medians.

Keep in mind what each number buys. The home care median is the aide's hourly rate. It doesn't pay the mortgage, the groceries or the utilities your parent already covers at home. The assisted living median is for a community whose services, per NIA, typically include meals, housekeeping and 24-hour supervision.,

Also, these are medians, not quotes. CareScout collects rates by metropolitan area and warns that actual costs vary with care needs, provider availability and local markets. In its 2025 survey, CareScout also merged homemaker and home health aide services into one "non-medical caregiver" category. For your state's figures, see our cost of senior care by state guide.

Who Pays: Medicare, Medicaid and Everything Else

Medicare

Here's the part that surprises most families. Medicare Part A and Part B don't pay for the custodial care an assisted living facility provides, meaning non-medical help with dressing, bathing and using the bathroom, according to Medicare.gov and federal regulation (42 CFR 411.15(g)). That exclusion is the core reason Medicare doesn't pay for a long-term stay in assisted living. A Medicare Supplement (Medigap) policy doesn't fill the gap either: Medicare.gov says Medicare and most health insurance, including Medigap, don't pay for long-term care services.

Hospice is the exception. If your parent is eligible (certified terminally ill with a life expectancy of 6 months or less), Medicare.gov says Medicare-approved hospice care can usually be given in the assisted living facility where they live, though you may have to pay for room and board if your parent lives in a facility and chooses hospice.

At home, the rule is similar. Original Medicare doesn't pay for non-skilled help with bathing, dressing, eating or using the bathroom when that custodial care is the only care needed, except as part of hospice care. What Medicare's home health benefit does cover at home is part-time or intermittent skilled nursing and therapy, which has no fixed time limit as long as it stays medically necessary and a doctor re-orders it every 60 days.,

That benefit has its own eligibility rules; our Medicare home health eligibility guide walks through them, and Medicare and assisted living covers the facility side.

Medicaid

Medicaid splits the two settings in a way families don't expect. According to the Medicaid and CHIP Payment and Access Commission (MACPAC), nursing facility services and home health services are the only two mandatory Medicaid long-term care benefits. Everything else, including home and community-based services such as personal care attendants and adult day care, is optional for states.

Here's how that works in practice. States can provide that optional help under the state plan or through waiver programs, MACPAC says, and one route is a Home and Community-Based Services (HCBS) 1915(c) waiver. These waivers can cover homemaker, home health aide, personal care and respite care, per Medicaid.gov. To qualify, your parent must need the level of care the state would require for an institution, and each state chooses the maximum number of people its waiver serves. That cap is why waiting lists exist.,

For assisted living, Medicare.gov says your parent may be able to get long-term care through Medicaid if they meet their state's eligibility requirements. The short answer on who pays: it depends on the community. One that takes Medicaid payment has to meet the non-institutional standards the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) set in 2014, per ASPE, so it isn't supposed to operate like an institution. What Medicaid pays for inside assisted living, and what stays your parent's bill, depends on the state; our how to pay for assisted living guide covers it, and HCBS waivers by state lists each state's programs.,

Income isn't the only bar. Per ACL, to qualify for Medicaid long-term care your parent's income must be below a certain level and they must meet minimum state eligibility requirements, which are based on how much help a person needs with activities of daily living, such as bathing and dressing.

Everything else

ACL says you will have to pay for long-term care services that no public or private insurance program covers. Private sources include savings, home equity, life insurance and annuities. Long-term care insurance has its own rules, eligibility requirements, copayments and premiums, and VA benefits pay for long-term care only for specific populations and in certain circumstances. Start with how to pay for in-home care, long-term care insurance, and, for veterans and surviving spouses, VA Aid and Attendance for home care or assisted living.

Who's in Charge of the Care?

This one gets less attention than cost, and it matters every single day. In a facility like assisted living, how much choice your parent gets varies. ACL says they may not get to choose who delivers services and may have limited say in when staff arrive, and you generally can't hire someone independently. They should still have choices about which staff members provide care, their schedule and their meals.

At home, ACL describes participant-directed services that let your parent control what services they get, who provides them (which can include family and friends), and how and when those services are delivered, including whether to use a home care agency at all.

Hiring an aide yourself works differently from going through an agency. Our guide to hiring in-home help explains the difference between the two routes.

When Home Care Is the Better Fit

Home care tends to work when:

  • Your parent needs help for part of the day, like mornings and bath days, rather than around the clock.
  • Family can cover some hours and paid help fills the gaps.
  • Staying in their own home, with their own routines, matters a lot to your parent.
  • The house is safe to live in, or can be made safe.
  • Your parent needs part-time skilled nursing or therapy, which Medicare can cover at home when it's medically necessary, alongside a few hours of personal care.

ACL notes that most people want to stay in their homes as long as possible and delay facility care until they need it.

When Assisted Living Is the Better Fit

Assisted living tends to make more sense when:

If your parent is married and the other spouse is the one holding things together, the same questions apply to both of them: can the spouse safely keep providing care, and what would be left at home if one of them moved? Price that before deciding. Adult day care and respite care, covered below, can give the spouse a break in the meantime, and your Area Agency on Aging can point you to local options.

If your parent needs ongoing medical care, neither option may be enough. NIA describes nursing homes as the setting for people who can't care for themselves anymore and may need ongoing medical care; see assisted living vs. nursing home and nursing home vs. home care.

What If Your Parent Has Dementia?

This is often the hardest version of the decision, and many families feel they're breaking a promise to keep a parent at home. Dementia changes the timeline: ACL says people with dementia can stay at home for some time, but for most, there will come a time when professional help or living in a facility becomes necessary.

When that time comes, memory care is one option. ACL describes specialized dementia care facilities, also known as "memory care" assisted living, as a specialized form of assisted living that generally offers supports beyond traditional assisted living; specialized staff training and secured exits are examples of what can be part of one. The resident pays for the room or apartment and may have to pay extra for special care. Ask any community you visit exactly what its dementia supports are and what costs extra, and whether your parent could stay if their needs grow.

Compare the options in our memory care by state guide.

Options in Between

It doesn't have to be all one or all the other. ACL says that for many people a blended approach to long-term care works best.

How to Decide, Step by Step

1
Step 1

Count the hours

Write down when your parent needs help across a full week, including nights. That number drives the cost more than anything else.

2
Step 2

Price both locally

Get written rates from two or three home care agencies and two or three assisted living communities near your parent, and ask each side the same questions. For agencies: is there a minimum shift length, what do overnights cost, who covers a call-out, and how are the aides screened and licensed? For communities: what triggers a move to a higher level of care, what does each level add, and what happens if your parent's needs outgrow the community? Our guides to choosing an assisted living facility and hiring in-home help go deeper, and get any contract or agreement in writing before you sign. Remember that if your parent moves, the costs of keeping their home (mortgage or rent, taxes, utilities) may continue.

3
Step 3

Check Medicaid early

If money is tight, ask your state Medicaid agency, or your local Area Agency on Aging through the Eldercare Locator (1-800-677-1116), whether your parent could qualify and whether your state's waiver has a waiting list; our HCBS waivers by state guide lists each state's programs. If there is a wait, family help and part-time paid hours can bridge it. Veterans and surviving spouses should also look at VA Aid and Attendance (see home care or assisted living) before choosing a setting.

4
Step 4

Ask your parent

This is often a hard conversation, and it's rarely a one-time decision. Who they want helping them, and where, is part of the answer. If they resist paid help or a move, start with their worries, such as privacy, cost or leaving home, and try a small step first, like a few hours a week.

5
Step 5

Plan for change

Needs often grow. Write down the triggers that would make you revisit the plan, such as needing help at night or paid hours nearing 41 a week. A plan that starts with home care and names the point where you'd look at assisted living saves a rushed decision later.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it cheaper to have a caregiver at home or assisted living?

It depends on the hours. Home care is billed by the hour, at a CareScout 2025 national median of $35, so part-time help can cost less than assisted living, while past about 41 hours a week the CareScout 2025 national medians favor assisted living. To test your own case, multiply a local agency's hourly rate by the hours your parent needs each week and by 52, then compare that total with a local assisted living community's monthly rate times 12, including any level-of-care fees.

Does Medicare pay for home care or assisted living?

Outside of hospice care, Medicare doesn't pay for custodial care (help with bathing, dressing and eating) in either place when that's the only care needed, which is why it doesn't pay for a long-term stay in assisted living. Medicare does cover part-time or intermittent skilled nursing and therapy at home when it's medically necessary.,

Can Medicaid pay for home care instead of assisted living?

It can, depending on your state. Home health is a mandatory Medicaid benefit, while personal care and other home and community-based services are optional and, per MACPAC, can be provided under the state plan or through waivers, which can cap enrollment.

When should someone move from home care to assisted living?

Common signs are needing help at night or at unpredictable times, paid home care hours running past full-time, isolation, or family caregivers who can't keep up. For someone with dementia, ACL says most people will eventually need professional help or a facility.

Learn More

Find personalized help deciding between assisted living and home care for your parent at brevy.com.


The information on Brevy.com is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional legal, financial, or medical advice. Rules vary by state and program and change frequently. Always verify with the relevant agency or a qualified professional. Brevy is not a law firm, financial advisor, or healthcare provider.

Still have questions?

Brevy answers from this guide and every other guide here, and can check what you qualify for.

BC

Brevy Care Team

Expert eldercare guidance from Brevy's team of healthcare professionals and researchers.