If a California nursing home has given you a notice of discharge, you can appeal to the state, and filing the appeal normally stops the discharge while it is pending. The appeal goes to the California Department of Health Care Services (DHCS), through its Office of Administrative Hearings and Appeals (OAHA), and only the resident or the resident's authorized representative can request it.

In This Guide

Can a California nursing home discharge a resident?

A discharge notice is alarming to get, but the resident has real protections: a right to written notice, a right to appeal, and normally at least 30 days to act.

A California nursing home may discharge a resident only for one of six reasons, and it must document the reason. Federal rules at 42 CFR 483.15 allow a transfer or discharge only when:

  • the move is necessary for the resident's welfare and their needs cannot be met in the facility
  • the resident's health has improved enough that they no longer need the facility's services
  • the resident's clinical or behavioral status endangers the safety of others in the facility
  • the health of others in the facility would otherwise be endangered
  • the resident has failed to pay after reasonable and appropriate notice
  • the facility closes

California's Health and Safety Code section 1599.1 applies those federal rules to every skilled nursing facility and intermediate care facility in the state, regardless of the resident's payment source or the facility's Medi-Cal or Medicare certification. So a private-pay resident has the same right to written notice and to appeal as one on Medi-Cal.

Nonpayment is the reason families worry about most, and it has limits. Nonpayment applies if the resident does not submit the paperwork needed for third-party payment, or after Medicare or Medicaid denies the claim and the resident refuses to pay. A resident who becomes eligible for Medicaid after admission can be charged only the allowable Medicaid charges. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) surveyor guidance also says a resident cannot be discharged for nonpayment while a decision on their Medicaid eligibility is pending.

The national rules are covered in more depth in our guide to nursing home discharge rights. What follows is the California procedure.

What must the discharge notice say?

Under federal rules, which California applies, a nursing home must give the resident and their representative written notice in a language and manner they understand, at least 30 days before a transfer or discharge. The California Department of Public Health (CDPH) lists four situations where notice can come as soon as practicable instead: the clinical or behavioral status of the resident endangers the health or safety of others in the facility, the resident's health has improved enough to allow a more immediate move, urgent medical needs require an immediate move, or the resident has not lived in the facility for 30 days. The federal contents list in the table below comes from 42 CFR 483.15(c)(5), which requires the notice to include the reason, its effective date and the location the resident is moving to. The appeal and ombudsman rows are also federal requirements, and CDPH tells California facilities to name DHCS OAHA as the appeal entity.

The notice must include What to check
The reason for the discharge It should match one of the six permitted reasons above
The effective date At least 30 days out, unless an exception applies
The location the resident is moving to A named place, not "home" or "the community" with no plan behind it
The right to appeal, and the name, address and phone number of the entity that takes appeal requests In California, that entity is DHCS OAHA
How to get an appeal form and help filling it out Ask the facility if the notice is silent
The name, address and phone number of the state Long-Term Care Ombudsman The notice is also supposed to go to the ombudsman

California adds duties on top of the federal rules:

  • The facility must send a copy of the notice to the local ombudsman at the same time it notifies the resident or representative, and a late copy is a class B violation.
  • Within 48 hours of the written notice, it must give the resident and representative a copy of the discharge evaluation and discharge plan.
  • If the stated reason is that the nursing home cannot meet the resident's needs, it must also provide a written description of the needs it cannot meet, what it did to meet them, and the services the receiving facility offers.
  • It must provide the discharge summary before the move date.
  • It must provide the evaluation, plan and summary free of charge.

If the 48 hours pass and nothing has arrived, ask in writing, and mention it to the ombudsman.

How do you file a California nursing home discharge appeal?

The whole filing step is one request to OAHA, the DHCS office that hears these appeals through its Transfer Discharge and Refusal to Readmit Unit. Only the resident or the resident's authorized representative can request a hearing. To file, call (916) 445-9775 or fax (916) 440-5105. This is not a State Hearing from the California Department of Social Services (CDSS), which Medi-Cal uses for benefit denials and reductions.

When you call, expect a series of questions. Have these ready:

On timing, DHCS's instruction is to submit the request as soon as possible, so a decision can come before the proposed discharge date. Federal law adds that a state must allow a reasonable time to request the hearing, not more than 90 days from the date the notice is mailed, and that the hearing body and the actual deadline are set by each state. Treat the 30-day notice period as your working deadline and file in the first days, whether or not you feel ready.

Does a nursing home discharge appeal stop the discharge in California?

Normally, yes. When a resident appeals a discharge notice, the facility may not transfer or discharge the resident while the appeal is pending. The one exception is a facility that can show staying would endanger the health or safety of the resident or others, and the facility must document that danger. CMS surveyor guidance treats a discharge that goes ahead during an appeal, without documentation of that danger, as possible noncompliance that surveyors are told to examine.

Being pressured to sign a parent out while their home is at stake is exhausting, and you do not have to handle it alone. If the facility moves the resident anyway, or pressures the family to sign them out, call the ombudsman the same day. Federal guidance says a resident who leaves against medical advice under pressure needs further investigation of whether the facility met its discharge duties.

What is the hearing like?

OAHA's hearings are generally held by telephone, and the resident or authorized representative must take part. That means you should plan a quiet, private place and a phone that will not drop, with your documents in front of you, because the hearing officer takes sworn testimony and records the hearing.

The burden of proof is on the nursing home: it has to present evidence that its action is appropriate and follows federal and state law. You are not asked to prove the facility wrong, only to hear its case and answer it. You can also present testimony, including from witnesses you compel to attend, so think early about who saw the events behind the notice, such as a nurse, an aide or the resident's doctor.

Three things help a family prepare:

  • The notice, the discharge plan and the other documents the facility owed you within 48 hours.
  • A statement from the resident's own physician, if the facility says the resident's needs cannot be met. Federal rules require the facility to document that basis in the medical record, with the specific needs it says it cannot meet and what it did to meet them.
  • The name of the person at the receiving location, and what that place can actually provide. The notice must name the location.

After the hearing, the hearing officer writes the Department's final decision, called a Decision & Order. It grants, denies or dismisses the appeal and sets out any remedy ordered.

What happens after the decision?

If the decision is in the resident's favor, federal rules require the state to promptly make corrective payments and, if appropriate, to provide for admission or readmission to a facility. If the facility discharged the resident anyway, a resident or representative who won the appeal may report the discharge to the State Survey Agency as a complaint. The agency cannot cite the facility based only on the ruling, but it must triage the complaint and investigate compliance with the discharge requirements. CMS guidance says that where the resident's health or safety is threatened in the new setting, the facility's plan of correction should either readmit the resident until a safe discharge can be done or arrange a transfer to a safe setting.

A win on paper does not always mean a bed. In Anderson v. Ghaly (2019), three former California nursing home residents had each won a state appeal of a refusal to readmit them, and none had been readmitted. The Ninth Circuit held that residents can sue over the state's failure to provide a fair appeal mechanism, and that the right includes the state carrying out the decision, though it sent the complaint back for repleading rather than ruling for the residents. If an order is not being followed, tell the ombudsman and ask for the legal services referral described below.

If the appeal is denied or dismissed, the Decision & Order is the Department's final administrative decision. Our sources do not publish how long a decision takes, or what further review is available and by when, so ask OAHA and the ombudsman about both at the start, and do not wait for the decision to begin planning. The notice has to name the location the resident is moving to, so keep asking for a specific, named destination and what it can provide.

Who can help for free?

Start with the California Long-Term Care Ombudsman Program. Ombudsman programs are federally mandated advocates for nursing home residents, and their services are free and confidential. The ombudsman's statewide hotline, 1-800-231-4024, takes calls from long-term care residents 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. The facility's discharge notice is supposed to carry the ombudsman's contact details.

The ombudsman is not a law firm. Federal rules do not require ombudsman programs to provide legal services, but they do require the program to help residents seek legal remedies and to promote the availability of legal counsel. The Administration for Community Living's (ACL) own example of an involuntary discharge describes an ombudsman referring the resident to a nonprofit legal services program to file the hearing request, or accompanying the resident to the hearing for support. The ombudsman can start that referral on the first call, which is why it is the best first call to make: it can connect you to free legal help before the hearing date.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need a lawyer to file?

The resident or an authorized representative can request the hearing by phone or fax, so a lawyer is not needed to file. Because the hearing involves sworn testimony and the facility has to prove its case, the ombudsman can refer you to a legal services program before the hearing date.

The nursing home says Medicare stopped paying. Is that a reason to discharge?

Nonpayment is one of the six reasons, but not while a Medicaid eligibility decision is pending. Our guide to when Medicare ends and Medicaid is still pending covers that situation.

What if the hospital will not send my parent back to the nursing home?

Under federal rules, a nursing home that decides a resident who was transferred cannot return must follow the same transfer and discharge requirements as for any discharge. See what to do when a nursing home refuses to readmit.

Is this the same as a Medi-Cal State Hearing?

No. A Medi-Cal benefit denial goes to a State Hearing, covered in our guide to California Medi-Cal appeals.

Learn More

Find personalized help responding to a California nursing home discharge notice at brevy.com.


The information on Brevy.com is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional legal, financial, or medical advice. Rules vary by state and program and change frequently. Always verify with the relevant agency or a qualified professional. Brevy is not a law firm, financial advisor, or healthcare provider.

Still have questions?

Brevy answers from this guide and every other guide here, and can check what you qualify for.

BC

Brevy Care Team

Expert eldercare guidance from Brevy's team of healthcare professionals and researchers.