Nobody warns you that the first day of being your mother's paid caregiver starts with electronic visit verification: an app telling you to clock in at her front door. If you're a family caregiver paid through Medicaid for personal care or home health services that need an in-home visit, being asked to use that app is normal: federal law makes your state require it. If you live with the person you care for, the rules may differ. None of that makes it feel less strange. What electronic visit verification records is a short federal list; how it works where you live is your state's call.

In This Guide

Yes, Family Caregivers Really Do Have to Clock In With EVV

The instruction isn't your case manager's preference, and it isn't a judgment about you. Congress wrote electronic visit verification into federal law in 2016. Section 12006 of the 21st Century Cures Act added section 1903(l) to the Social Security Act, which requires states to use an electronic visit verification system for Medicaid personal care services and home health care services that require an in-home visit by a provider. The federal electronic visit verification deadline for Medicaid personal care services was January 1, 2020, and Medicaid home health care services followed on January 1, 2023.

Section 1903(l) is a Medicaid rule, written for Medicaid personal care and home health services. If you're paid through a program other than Medicaid, ask that program directly whether it requires visit verification of its own.

The reason states press so hard on this is financial, and it explains the tone. Under Section 1903(l) of the Social Security Act, a state that does not require electronic visit verification for Medicaid personal care and home health services loses federal matching money on a written schedule that climbs to a full 1 percentage point of the federal match for personal care services from 2023 onward, and for home health care services from 2027 onward. The EVV penalty applies only to personal care and home health dollars, not to a state's whole federal match.

So when the financial management agency that issues your pay (some states call it a fiscal intermediary) chases you about an unverified visit, that's the machinery behind it, and it isn't discretionary at their end either. The Cures Act sets a floor and leaves the rest to your state, which is why your neighbor two states over can have a different app and different rules about fixing mistakes.

The Six Things Electronic Visit Verification Records at Every Visit

Federal law is unusually specific here, and the list is more reassuring than imagining it. An electronic visit verification system has to electronically verify six things about each visit:

  1. The type of service performed
  2. The individual receiving the service
  3. The date of the service
  4. The location of service delivery
  5. The individual providing the service
  6. The time the service begins and ends

That is the whole federal list, and it maps onto what a paper timesheet has always asked: who, for whom, what, where, when it started, when it stopped.

Your state can add to that list. What it cannot do is satisfy the federal list with a timesheet alone. CMS was asked in 2019 whether a web-based timesheet with the client signing off would count, and answered no, because "web-based timesheets alone do not provide the state with auditable confirmation of the data entered by the provider and approved by the individual." That is why the app exists at all.

Is It Tracking Me All Day?

The federal floor is narrower than the fear: capturing where a visit starts and where it stops is enough to satisfy it, and your state may require more.

CMS put this in writing when asked how EVV could minimize privacy concerns: "The Cures Act does not require states to capture each location as the individual is moving throughout the community." CMS went on: "Services either starting or stopping in the individual's home are subject to EVV requirements, and capturing the location in which the service is started and stopped is sufficient for meeting the minimum requirements specified in the Cures Act."

CMS was equally direct about the technology. "CMS also notes that there is no requirement to use global positioning services (GPS), but it is one approach for implementation of the EVV requirements. A common alternative to GPS is Interactive Voice Response, which requires the caregiver to check-in and out using a landline or cellular device located at the individual's home." GPS is allowed; the law just didn't make it the only option.

The federal rule is a floor, not a ceiling, though. In the same answer, "CMS notes that states may choose to require more information as a factor to control for fraud, waste, and abuse." What your particular system records is a question about your state's vendor, not about the Cures Act.

What about the afternoon you take your mother to the pharmacy? CMS addressed that too: "EVV is only required for the portion of the service rendered in the home," though the same bulletin adds that "states may choose to require more information to control fraud, waste, and abuse." At least one state describes its own system that way: Hawaii Med-QUEST says on its EVV page that "The devices only capture information at the start and end of a visit."

If You Live With the Person You Care For

The federal answer here sits in a 2019 CMS bulletin, and it may surprise you.

CMS was asked directly whether EVV requirements apply when the person receiving care lives with the caregiver providing it. The answer was: "No, EVV requirements do not apply when the caregiver providing the service and the beneficiary live together." The reasoning is that "PCS or HHCS rendered by an individual living in the residence does not constitute an 'in-home visit'." If you moved into your father's house to care for him, or he into yours, the federal mandate doesn't reach that arrangement.

But read the rest of CMS's answer before you make a phone call about it, because the second half is what decides your case. "However, states are encouraged to apply appropriate oversight to services provided in these circumstances to curb fraud, waste and abuse. Additionally, states may choose to implement EVV in these instances, particularly when using discrete units of reimbursement, such as on an hourly basis."

So the federal exemption is real, and your state can decline it. States have gone both ways, and the two examples below are not a survey of all fifty:

  • Ohio treats it as something you apply for. The Ohio Department of Medicaid Electronic Visit Verification Resource Guide, updated April 28, 2026, answers the question "Do providers have to participate in EVV if they live with the person receiving services?" with: "Providers who live in the same household as the person receiving services can request an EVV exemption using the live-in caregiver online request form." The Ohio guide adds that live-in caregivers requesting the exemption "must upload documentation to confirm the shared address."
  • Hawaii went the other way. Hawaii Med-QUEST's EVV FAQs page, answering whether EVV applies when the person receiving care lives with the caregiver, says: "Hawaii has chosen to include the use of EVV for live-in caregivers as this curbs and prevents fraud, waste and abuse."

If you share an address with the person you care for, ask your state Medicaid agency one specific question: does this state exempt live-in caregivers from EVV, and if it does, what do I file? If you're not sure which office that is, Medicaid.gov keeps a state-by-state list of Medicaid agency contacts.

What Happens If a Visit Doesn't Verify

The question that keeps people up is simple: you forgot to clock out, or the app crashed, and you've just worked six hours the system has no record of. Are you paid?

Your state answers this one. Section 1903(l) lists the six data elements and the duties it places on states implementing the system, and none of those items sets a deadline for correcting a visit. Looking closely at one state's rules shows you which questions to ask about your own.

Take Texas, where fixing an incomplete visit record is called visit maintenance, and it has a clock: visit maintenance, including manually entering a visit an employee failed to clock, must be completed within 95 calendar days from the date of service delivery, though the Texas Health and Human Services Commission may extend that window. After that window expires, the Texas EVV system locks the visit transaction, and the only way back in is a Visit Maintenance Unlock Request.

That unlock is narrower than it sounds. Texas payers will approve a Visit Maintenance Unlock Request only where a state or proprietary EVV system error wasn't resolved inside the 95-day visit maintenance window (and the request shows the payer was told about the error inside that window and a good faith effort was made to meet it), or where HHSC determines an exception is required for something like a payer error or a natural disaster. Texas also directs that payers may not approve an unlock request where the caregiver simply failed to clock in or out and nothing stopped the visit being entered inside the Texas 95-day window. In plain terms: in Texas a forgotten punch is fixable, the fix has a deadline, and after it usually isn't.

Texas also decides in advance who does that fixing. A Texas consumer-directed services employer, the person who holds the employer role for the worker, picks one of three options on a Texas HHSC form:

  1. The employer performs all visit maintenance and approves the employee's time.
  2. The financial management agency performs the maintenance, and the employer approves the time.
  3. The agency performs the maintenance and confirms the time based on the employer's approval documentation.

Those are Texas's rules, not your state's unless you live there. What carries over is the questions: how long do I have to correct a visit, who has the authority to correct it, and what happens when that window closes? Ask whoever pays you, before the first mistake rather than after it.

No Smartphone, No Signal, Dead Battery

The federal guarantee here is smaller than you'd hope, but it isn't nothing.

CMS was asked whether an EVV system requires the Medicaid beneficiary to have an internet connection, a cell phone, or a landline, and answered: "No. CMS notes that there are a number of options available within an EVV system. CMS believes there are EVV system options that meet the six verification criteria specified in the legislation without relying upon a Medicaid beneficiary to supply any technology, including those in which the provider has a phone or electronic tracker available to staff and/or the service recipient." That answer is about what the system may require of the person receiving care, not about which of those options your own state has chosen to offer.

Beyond that, the answer is your state's, so it's worth asking early which options yours offers. Texas, again as one worked example, approves exactly three ways to clock in and out:

  • A mobile app on a smartphone or other internet-connected device. It's the only approved method when a visit begins or ends out in the community.
  • The person's home landline.
  • A standalone alternative device, which needs neither a smartphone nor a landline.

If a Texas caregiver can't use the app for a visit that starts or ends in the community, the visit isn't lost: they document the visit data under program policy instead, though Texas counts a manually entered visit against the EVV Usage Score.

The no-phone device is the limited option. Texas caps how many it hands out free and is phasing down how often providers can rely on them, so if you think you'll need one, ask your financial management agency early whether one is available to you.

If your phone dies mid-visit, don't guess. Write down the actual start and stop times immediately, in ink, and call your financial management agency the same day to ask how their system wants that visit recorded. While you have them, ask how long your state's window for fixing it stays open, and whether a backup method, such as a landline at the person's home, is approved where you live.

What the Law Says EVV Can't Be Used to Do

The fear under the clock-in fear is usually bigger than the app: if they can track when I'm in the house, how long before somebody decides I'm not the right person to be caring for her?

Congress wrote something about that. Section 12006(c)(3) of the Cures Act, printed as a construction note to 42 U.S.C. 1396b, says: "Nothing in the amendment made by this section may be construed to limit, with respect to personal care services or home health care services provided under a State plan under title XIX of the Social Security Act (or under a waiver of the plan) (42 U.S.C. 1396 et seq.), provider selection, constrain beneficiaries' selection of a caregiver, or impede the manner in which care is delivered."

The same section says the amendment can't be read to require one particular or uniform electronic visit verification system to be used by every agency or entity that provides these services. CMS describes the same latitude from the state's side, writing that "states have significant discretion to utilize the system(s) of their choosing. CMS does not endorse one type of system over another."

Two honest limits on all of that. First, these are rules of construction: they govern how the EVV amendment is read, they are not a complaint process, and nothing here tells you that you have an appeal if your state's system does get in the way. Second, none of it disarms your state. Paragraph (4) of the same section provides that nothing in the amendment bars a State from establishing quality-measure requirements for its EVV system.

Your State Has to Offer You Training

If somebody handed you a phone and a login and walked away, that isn't how this was supposed to go.

Section 1903(l) of the Social Security Act, in the same subsection that creates the EVV mandate, tells states to ensure that individuals who furnish personal care services or home health care services "are provided the opportunity for training on the use of such system." It also tells states to consult with the agencies and entities providing those services so the system "is minimally burdensome," takes account of systems already in use in the state, and runs in line with HIPAA privacy and security law. And it tells states to take into account a stakeholder process that includes input from beneficiaries, family caregivers, and the people actually furnishing the services. That training language is a duty the statute places on your state, not an individual right it hands you.

Family caregivers are named in the statute, so you are not an afterthought in this system on paper, whatever it feels like in practice. If nobody has trained you, asking your financial management agency for that training is a reasonable request, and your state is the party the law tells to make it available.

Which EVV Rules Are Federal and Which Are Your State's?

Your question Who decides What's settled
Do I have to clock in at all? Federal Yes, for Medicaid personal care and home health services needing an in-home visit
What gets recorded each visit? Federal floor, state can add The six elements are the minimum; a state may require more
Is my location tracked between clock-in and clock-out? Federal floor, state can add Start-and-stop capture meets the federal minimum, and GPS isn't required by it
Which app or device do I use? Your state CMS says states have significant discretion to choose their system; the Cures Act doesn't require one uniform system across all providers
Am I exempt because I live with her? Federal by default, state can override Federal rules don't reach a live-in caregiver, and a state may still require EVV
How long do I have to fix a missed punch? Your state None of the Cures Act's six data elements or state duties sets one; Texas allows 95 days
Do I get paid if a visit never verifies? Your state Your state's rules decide; Texas locks the visit after 95 days
Who fixes the record, me or the agency? Your state In Texas the consumer-directed services employer picks one of three options

The rows in the bottom half are the ones that decide your paycheck, and your state is where you get those answers. Knowing which of your questions has a federal answer saves you from arguing the wrong point with the wrong office.

Two offices matter: your state Medicaid agency, and the financial management agency or fiscal intermediary that issues your pay. For a specific visit, correction, or deadline, the second is usually the better place to start.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do family caregivers have to use EVV, or is it only for agency workers?

Electronic visit verification applies to a Medicaid personal care or home health visit whether the person providing it is the beneficiary's daughter or a stranger from an agency: the federal requirement attaches to the service, not to your relationship. The federal carve-out to know about is living in the same home, and your state can choose to apply EVV anyway.

Does EVV know where I am between clocking in and clocking out?

Federal EVV rules don't require it. CMS has written that capturing where the service starts and stops meets the federal minimum, and that the Cures Act doesn't require states to track a caregiver through the community. CMS also says states may choose to require more, so ask whoever runs your system what it records.

What happens if I forget to clock in or out?

Your state decides whether that visit can still be corrected and paid, and how long you have to do it. In Texas, required visit maintenance must be completed within 95 calendar days of the date of service delivery, and Texas directs payers not to approve a later unlock request where a caregiver simply failed to clock in or out and nothing stopped the visit being entered in time. Write down the real start and stop times immediately and call the agency that pays you the same day.

What if I don't own a smartphone?

Your state decides which clock-in methods it approves; Texas, as one worked example, approves a mobile app, the person's home landline, and a standalone alternative device that needs neither. The federal guidance addresses the person receiving care rather than the caregiver: CMS says an EVV system does not require the Medicaid beneficiary to supply an internet connection, a cell phone, or a landline.

How do I find out which EVV system my state uses?

Your state chooses its own system. Check your state Medicaid agency's website for an EVV page, or ask the financial management agency that pays you which vendor and app it uses. Ohio, for example, contracts with Sandata to run its EVV system. If you don't know your state's Medicaid agency, Medicaid.gov keeps a state-by-state contact list.

Can they cut my hours or replace me over EVV data?

Section 12006(c) of the 21st Century Cures Act says its EVV amendment may not be construed to "constrain beneficiaries' selection of a caregiver, or impede the manner in which care is delivered." That is a limit on how the law is read rather than a complaint process, so it does not by itself give you a remedy. Raise a specific decision with your case manager or the agency that authorized the service.

Learn More

Find personalized help sorting out your state's electronic visit verification rules at brevy.com.


The information on Brevy.com is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional legal, financial, or medical advice. Rules vary by state and program and change frequently. Always verify with the relevant agency or a qualified professional. Brevy is not a law firm, financial advisor, or healthcare provider.

Still have questions?

Brevy answers from this guide and every other guide here, and can check what you qualify for.

BC

Brevy Care Team

Expert eldercare guidance from Brevy's team of healthcare professionals and researchers.